Obviously No.........We live in a State with absolute disparity. Rich are very rich & poor are very poor. Those who have power are obsessed with it & those who don’t have it, are suppressed by it. If the deficiencies are not distributed equally in the society, how can you distribute the resources equally?
You should remember the Merit you have got is not only the Product of your Ability & Efforts but also of the Environment (physical, social, intellectual, genetic, & financial) you have got.
People forget that the Aim of Reservation was to Break the Core of Casteism.
There was a time when people of lower castes were not able to even think that they can achieve higher positions in their lives. Age old suppression has made them think that they are not capable of it. In the previous times, society & all its wealth was completely divided according to the caste hierarchy. This casteism has created such a big divide in the society that the Upper Castes were full of Superiority & the Lower Castes were full of Inferiority. Reservations were made to bridge this gap.
Yes, things have changed since then but only on the Peripheral Issues. Today a Brahman will eat & drink with a Harijan, & will treat him well. But he will never marry his daughter to him. Because Endogamy (marriages within the same castes) is a core attribute of casteism.
People say that the benefit of reservations only reach to those who are already affluent but they fail to realize that 100 other not effluent peoples of their castes also get motivated by seeing people of their castes reaching place. They also start feeling that they & their kids can also reach to those positions someday.
I know that Reservation is a partial tool in the sense that it gives preference to one person over other based on his caste, religion, & physical disability. But the aim of its formulation was to create equality in the society in terms of caste, religion, gender or physical disability. Actually what it is doing right now is that it is bargaining the caste system with the class system.
The Best Example of Reservation vs Casteism is of a Lower Caste Manager (LCM) & Higher Caste Chaprasee (HCC). Where the HCC satisfies his ego saying that: “ki hoga sala manager office mein, hai to chamar hi (pardon my language)......& the LCM satisfies his ego saying that: " ki hoga sala Brahman apne ghar mein, hai to mera chaprasee hee”.
Whatever I have mentioned here are basic sociological facts & not mere examples from my own imagination. So those who are really interested in the issue should first go & read some good sociology Books on Casteism in India. Even I also feel that reservations should go some day from India. But only when we stop seeing caste based matrimonial, People stop inquiring about your sir names &, People stop judging your abilities & personalities based on your caste. I also dream about an India where Equity & Equality prevails in its absolute sense.....!!!